Active Versus Passive Investing Strategies: Unveiling The Winners From 1997 To 2025

There has been an age-old debate between the merits of active investment management and passive (buy-and-hold) strategies. The accompanying chart which tracks the performance of the top 10 largest stocks of 1997 to the present day provides valuable clues on the implications of long-term ownership of stocks.

Two of the groups, Intel and Altria (Philip Morris) declined over the past 28 years. A third company, General Electric (the largest company) rose modestly over the period and did not generate a positive inflation-adjusted return.

The remaining 7 companies posted respectable to very strong returns. Perhaps most surprising, in this supposedly post-fossil fuel world, was the strength of ExxonMobil which rose about 400%. Consumer products company Proctor Gamble also posted stronger returns than might be expected in a mature business.

The rest of the names, Microsoft, IBM, Merck and Johnson & Johnson all posted sold long-term returns due to their connection to the fast-growing Tech and healthcare industries.

The accompanying chart suggests that optimal returns can be generated by investors who pay attention to developing secular trends and valuations.

The steady decline in smoking rates that were apparent in 1997 argued against holding Altria. Similarly, the elevated valuation accorded Intel in 1997 because of the enthusiasm generated by the appearance of the Internet suggested long-term results would be uninspiring.

The chart suggests that serious investors seeking to maximize returns and mitigate risk would do well to adopt an active investment approach that considers macro factors such as industry trends as well as micro factors such as security valuation.

We share our analysis of unfolding events and investing activities each month in our paid service, the Global Investment Letter, which includes actionable investment ideas and updates on major stock, bond, currency and commodity markets. If you found this post insightful, imagine the value you’ll get out of the full letter. Subscribe now to our free weekly investment comment (exclusive to those who signup) and also gain access to free sample issues of the Global Investment Letter.

Join our growing community here: https://www.globalinvestmentletter.com/sample-issue/